For the first couple of years after planting my Edgeworthia, I fretted over the yellowing leaves, but as Carolyn noted, thats what they do. Carolyn. N.C. Click here to get to the home page of our website for catalogues and information about our nursery and to subscribe to our blog. I will try this when I can get one in a very protected spot. A definite plus in our area. Current catalogues are under Pages below. 3 Chemicals and Bioactivities Expand this section. Note this is the default cart. Hello, I am in zone 7b. In the summer you might mistake it for rhododendron. Grows 6' x 6', sun, part shade, shade, Z6b. It arrived fairly recently in the US. Carolyn, do you think mine might be struggling because it was brought from England which has a much wetter climate. Perhaps some other commenters could help. These hang on the bare branches and flood the garden with an exotic perfume, creating a sight and smell you will love. If you want to return to my blogs homepage to access the sidebar information (catalogues, previous articles, etc.) 9000 SE Division, Portland, OR 97266. It is deciduous and has large and distinctive leaves. It grows against the house with Southern exposure (otherwise not particularly protected) and no supplemental water. Tatyana, The drooping leaves are not a problem. I need to prune it but dont know when to prune because I love it in all seasons. Thank you, Carolyn. Edgeworthias leaves are large and tropical, and its bark is an unusual reddish-brown. Mine in Germantown on southeast side of house has bloomed nicely. Pbm, The post profiles Edgeworthia chrysantha. Are the leaves on your Edgeworthia exhibiting this behavior or are the leaves actually shriveling-up first and then falling off? Blooms in winter when leafless. I will continue to keep an eye on her and hope this winter goes well for both of us! Now the prior less hardy version, papyrifera, with a smaller leaf I would have hesitated to prune. Patty, My edgeworthia that faces northeast and is overhung by an azalea, a vibunum, and several conifers is thriving. Mine have set buds this summer while temps hovered in the 90s. Robyn, My edgeworthia in a more exposed site did not bloom last year either. Nancy, You must have liked the post. Usually marketed as 'Akebono' and mistranslated as 'Red Dragon' the Japanese word akebono means "dawn" or "daybreak" its name in Japan is 'Akabana', which . So Im getting from this blog that I should prune more severely in the early spring (ouch, scary!)?? Stored seed usually requires 8 - 12 weeks warm stratification at 20c followed by 12 - 14 weeks at 3c [6]. Tiny tubular flowers with no petals in dense umbels of 40 golden yellow flowers. I love the stark branch structure with the large silver buds in the winter. All the edgeworthias I have ever seen do that. Any advice will be greatly appreciated. As with any Internet translation, the conversion is not context-sensitive and may not translate the text to its original meaning. Not sure you can find this daphne in America, as it is very rare even in Europe. Origin: Found in the woodlands of the Himalayas and China. All the plants that I follow around here are extremely healthy. I have seen them go limp in very dry weather, but the pop right back if I catch it in time. How It Grows Paper bush spreads by rhizomes but isn't invasive, and generally forms a dense, slowly expanding clump of long, pliable stems. What a surprise to see this in PA, even in southeastern PA. Interesting post. It is so happy There is basic information about the nursery along with catalogues and a place to subscribe to the blog. I am sorry it has taken me two years to see your post. Glad to hear its normal! I never water mine and it thrives. English is the controlling language of this page. Life always gets in the way of gardening. I do not fertilize mine but you could try it. Dont over or under water and it will likely be fine. Subscribe By Email chevron_right. This well-branched, well-formed shrub begins forming its silvery buds in late summer into fall, adding interest to your fall garden. I think Cape Cod and southeastern PA are the same zone. I hope your Edgeworthia is doing well this year. What town and zone are you in? Maybe that is what is happening to yours. Carolyn. Superb in shape and form, Paperbush is a wonderful plant to combine with shade-tolerant evergreens and wildflowers. Liz, maybe an edgeworthia bonsai is in your future. What beautiful photos. Click here to get to the home page of our website for catalogues and information about our nursery and to subscribe to our blog. Perfect as a specimen plant, for shrub borders, foundation plantings, or containers. I know you have been busy, but did you see a post I did and linked to you? Al igual que con cualquier traduccin por Internet, la conversin no es sensible al contexto y puede que no traduzca el texto en su significado original. The day will come when drastic pruning will have to happen, but I am not looking forward to it. I looked up care for edgeworthia and happened onto your Blog. It formed buds on virtually all branches by Fall, but some appear to have shriveled in the cold of late winter, and none have blossomed yet. Hope that helps. A south-facing wall is best for growing this shrub, which likes moist, rich soil. As for me, my edgeworthia is thriving in zone 7 with temperature and weather conditions very similar to yours. At my old job we had one in the display garden that got little supplemental water during dry times, and although the plant lived through it, the flowers were puny the next winter. We have just had a lot of rain after a dry spell. Edgeworthia's flowers are a creamy yellow, tan, and white. It had smaller leaves, grew slower and smaller, and was significantly less cold hardy even for me in Atlanta. Botanical Name: Edgeworthia chrysantha Common Name: Paperbush Family: Thymelaceae Hardiness: USDA Zones 7-9 Size: 10' tall x 10' wide Location: Full shade to part sun Soil: Moist and well-drained Bloom Time: Winter Foliage: Deciduous with yellow fall color Happy Growing Overall, I am a huge fan of paperbush and I think you will be too! Want to see which lists are available? In my previous posts I described our huge and spectacular E. chrysantha which we had for fifteen years in Barnstable, Massachusetts. I love the open form, but I want to make sure there isnt anything wrong, such as a pest, disease, etc.which I cannot find any evidence of. I agree, it is the Belle of the winter Garden. Had hoped there were two in the pot, wanted to have a row of three. Carolyn. Genus: Edgeworthia Named for M.P. I love multi trunk trees like the Crape Myrtle, but already have quite a few in the front yard. Woody Ornamentals North Carolina Extension Gardener Handbook, Hanging Baskets, From Houseplants to Herbs, Mountain Horticultural Crops Research & Extension Center, Vernon G. James Research & Extension Center, Extension Gardener Travel Study Adventures, Entomology Insect Biology and Management, Mountain Horticultural Crops Research and Extension Center, Weed Management in Nurseries, Landscapes & Christmas Trees. Basically I had to water it every day not to have the leaves droop. Although here in piedmont NC we had a cold winter this year, we have had colder, so I dont think the low temperatures are the reason for our problem, I think I probably just didnt prune severely enough. Anne, I have never moved oneanyone can comment if they have. Hank, Akebono is not supposed to be hardy where we are. Edgeworthia chrysantha (compact form) Golden Paper Bush from China Edgeworthia chrysantha (pink throat) from China Edgeworthia chrysantha 'Winter Gold' from China Edgeworthia papyrifera 'Eco Yaku' from Japan Edgeworthia papyrifera (melon) But one must be out in the winter garden to experience. Fragrant gold flowers in February and big lush green leaves. It originates from China and the Himalayas and grows, as a small rounded shrub, to about 4 or 5ft in height (occasionally more in a heated glasshouse). Get all the details below! Although there is some confusion about this, Red Dragon is a cultivar of a different species of edgeworthia, E. papyerifera, which is less hardy as you found out. Liane, thanks for commenting on pruning. Thanks in advance! This edgeworthia is pictured in mid-April on the terrace of the main house at Chanticleer gardens in Wayne, Pennsylvania. [Note:Carolyns Shade Gardens is retail nursery located in Bryn Mawr, PA. Long, narrow, leathery, blue-green leaves up to 10 inches long give the shrub a tropical look. Im partial to her because a previous boss said it would never make it I am in zone 7a so not that far off from your zone. Edgeworthia chrysantha 'Grandiflora' is much sought after and makes a striking specimen shrub for exotic gardens and shady woodland borders. I got my first one from you about 6 or 7 years ago. Abstract The complete chloroplast genomes of three species of Edgeworthia namely, Edgeworthia albiflora, Edgeworthia chrysantha, and Edgeworthia gardnerindhF to the trnL-UAG genes. Need more advice on my Chrysantha. The plant does send up a lot of shoots from the base which could be allowed to grow and fill in the plant if you dont like the bare branches. Akebono did not make it through the winter, but Winter Gold flowered very well, in spite of another very cold March. Nursery Happenings: Carolyns Shade Gardens is a retail nursery located in Bryn Mawr, PA, specializing in showy, colorful, and unusual plants for shade. Create long-lasting, pleasing contrasts in your garden. Their scent will hang beautifully in the air! Carolyn. 3-5 inches long by 2 inches wide. Problems: None serious, but root rot can be an issue if over-watering occurs. Fully open flowers in my garden in mid-March 2012. In the summer, the plant is covered in beautiful, narrowly oval, dark blue-green leaves, 6 in. Great, Joyce, I am sure Alex and Practiced Hands Gardening can help. Maintenance on this plant is minimal, prune to remove diseases or damaged branches. Unless you can give up your Edgeworthia before it gets too large, then I would not plant one. Donna, Exotic is a good word for it, and it does engage the sense of touch with the silky buds. What a beautiful and elegant shrub! The present study was to elucidate the ultrastructure characteristics of the flower, the phytochemical composition of the aroma essential oil My Edgeworthia plant is healthy, but I notice the bottom leaves are turning yellow, do I need to fertilize or is this natural to the species? It also holds water and feeding ingredients in summer. Carolyn. This spring was a hard one for my Edgeworthias on Cape Cod. I have seen a couple of close up shots before, but dont recall seeing bush shots. I built the container using screws so I could take the container apart without destroying it when I needed to transplant my shrub. I bought one from you last spring and it did beautifully in the summer and fall, and late fall brought the tight white buds which I watched expectantly all through the winter. Also, I want ti transplant it now, not in Spring, as I will not be here then. It eventually reaches 7 feet high and wide and makes a nice stand-alone specimen or back-of-the-border choice. I have pruned one edgeworthia back to the ground when it became unstable on its large central stem on a slope (5-6 diameter) and it has sprouted and regrown beautifully. When the leaves drop, they reveal the slender and pliable reddish-brown bark seen above. My plants just grow lush green leaves and they keep growing without flowering or loosing their leaves. Both composted hardwood and ground pine bark suppress root rot. The leaves cluster at the tips of the branches giving the shrub a decidedly lush and tropical appearance that really stands out in the garden. It is now almost five feet tall. L'Edgeworthia (Edgeworthia chrysantha, famille des Thymlaces), appel aussi Edgeworthie ou buisson papier , est un trs joli arbuste buissonnant la silhouette harmonieuse et l'allure exotique.Il atteint entre 1 et 2 m de haut et une longvit jusqu' 60 ans. Another try for dry weather is Transatlantica Eternal Fragrance. Like its botanical cousin daphne, edgeworthia produces extremely fragrant, butterfly attracting flowers in the winter and early spring. I have one and live in southern England. Member Discounts. Good luck, Carolyn. We made the original selection from a group of seed-grown plants, imported from China by Canada's Piroche Plants in the late 1990s. But since your son Alex will be helping with our spring clean-up soon, Ill be asking his advice. I am wondering if you, Carolyn, have been able to locate any new ones. to see if it helps. The flowers are beautiful and the fragrance is amazing. I adore this plant and have one in my zone 7b garden (North Carolina), where it blooms in late February. Starr, I hope everyone understands that I am not recommending an edgeworthia for zone 5. Cold combined with wind seems to be the bigger enemy of this plant in zone 6b gardens as Carolyn and everyone I know in Pennsylvania with them has experienced. For catalogues and announcements of events, please send your full name, location, and phone number (for back up use only) to [email protected]. Read our Commitment to Diversity | Read our Privacy Statement. Pruning my be in my plants future too. Rosemary, I have never seen one growing in a pot. Louise, You must have figured the comment problem out. Plus, I believe I have it sited well. Edgeworthia thrives in partial shade and appreciates well-enriched, moist soil. Carolyn. I need to replant my Chrysantha now to a new shadier location on the side of a big fir tree and a bit elevated location so without a drainage in the hole which turned out bad. I am in zone 8/7B/Adepending on the year and climate of the current season. I just found two buds on my baby Edgeworthia. For years I have been removing the 50 or so suckers from the base of this plant, and last year I took about two feet off some of the tallest branches. I wanted to attach a picture but do not see an option to do it. I should have taken it out of the container last year. I think protection from winter winds is the most important consideration. In spring, after the blooms pass, it sports lovely bluish foliage with silvery undertones that are both eye-catching and soothing. Carolyn. Carolyn. Joyce, That must have been quite alarming. (Optional) Name: Edgeworthia chrysantha Common name: Paperbush Description: Deciduous shrub reaching 5-6 feet tall and wide. So glad to hear someone is growing one on Cape Cod as I am looking for a special plant for my mother! If there are any left I would like to try one in southeast Michigan zone 6 (now changed from zone 5) and will grow it in a protected place, maybe in a area that Japanese maples would like. These shrubs are nearly indestructible by human hand only the cold seems to take its toll. Read our Commitment to Diversity | Read our Privacy Statement. PubChem. Edgeworthiais a shrub native to China and the Himalayas thatprovides superb fall and winter interest and a gardenia-like fragrance. Please let me know when you have them for sale. Most sources say that edgeworthia grows in light to partial shade and requires moist, fertile, well-drained organic soil with supplemental water in summer. Planting in a protected location is often recommended, and all the plants I have seen are in protected spots, but I dont know if this is necessary. I did lose one of those to a particularly bad southern winter once! I am however loving my Winters Joy! I love it. http://www.seidelbast.net/ponticahybrid.html, https://carolynsshadegardens.com/2017/01/28/edgeworthia-update/, https://nurcar.com/collections/woodies-e/products/edgeworthia-chrysantha-winter-gold, Your Native Woodland: If You Build It They Will Come, Coastal Maine Botanical Gardens in Boothbay, ME, Ferns for American Gardens by John Mickel, Snowdrops by Matt Bishop, Aaron Davis, & John Grimshaw, The Gardener's Guide to Growing Hellebores by Graham Rice and Elizabeth Strangman. Follow this link https://carolynsshadegardens.com/2017/01/28/edgeworthia-update/ and please make a comment with your edgeworthia exeriences! You can see many dormant buds along each branch. A Google search revealed not much information other than one edgeworthia that had been moved three times successfully. I need advice as to the soil mix. However it gets very hot here in the summer, 90 to 100 degrees routinely in July and August and there is usually a drought. There is only one other species in the genus that I know of, E. papyrifera, and it may be just a subset of E. chrysantha. Sign up today! I have concluded that edgeworthias are perfectly hardy in our zone. Joy, There are so few edgeworthias in our area that I underestimated the size and planted it close to a very special Japanese maple and a thriving camellia. The only plants that we ship are snowdrops and miniature hostas. All the best It usually does not get below 8F here. The edgeworthias in our zone 7A area, which never went below freezing this winter, were damaged but not killed, although some didnt suffer at all. Hello Edgeworthia lovers, Im on the Board of Awbury Arboretum in Germantown, and our landscape manager there, Denis Lucey, says edgeworthia is his favorite shrub by far. I am glad you are enjoying it. My gut reaction would be that you are worrying about drainage too much. Donna, I only know of one nursery that supplies it down here. I would like to get another. I am going to try propogating from cutting soon but have heard its virtually impossible to do. However, mine sailed through our harsh winter with -10 F (10 degrees below our supposed zone low) and bloomed. Carolyn, We planted a whip of paper bark about 2 springs ago I, too, am ready to get one next growing season. I ordered the edgeworthia chrysantha from England. During those cold periods, the shrub cant take up moisture and the buds dry out and eventually shatter without blooming. Carolyn. It is not offered for sale up here by our suppliers and not grown at the tree and shrub nursery either. Department of Plant Sciences, University of Tennessee, Juniper Level Botanic Gardens: Part Sun-Part Shade Gardens, Border Landscape Pinewild County Club, Moore County, Mountain Ridge Top Garden - East Lawn and Lower Drive Border. By the way, the pruning did not affect new growth at all. I bought one at the Scott Arboretum sale in 2007 (?). Carolyn. My edgeworthias have organic soil but are in a dry location. The only plants that we ship are snowdrops and miniature hostas. I am on Cape Cod, but have been a customer of theirs for years. North Carolina citizens each year through local centers in the state's 100 counties Some literature says that there is no difference between the two species, but we think there is. I have no idea. Edgeworthia does have a sticky look to it. Carolyn. Love the snowflakes too! What an amazing looking plant. Large varieties can become up to 8 feet high . Propagate by root greenwood and semi-ripe nodal stem-tip cuttings in summer in free-draining compost. Fortunately, it responds well to pruning. The cold hardy camellia varieties work fine here, and the April Series are great. Flowers in clusters of 35 or more at branch tips, slightly fragrant, each flower is about 1.5 cm long, a 4-lobed silky calyx, white on the outside with a yellow . At least one member of the genus, Edgeworthia chrysantha, has the extremely unusual ability to branch trichotomously - the apical meristem forming the end of each stem splits into three sections at once. There are several varieties of Edgeworthia, including: Edgeworthia chrysantha 'Nanjing Gold', with yellow flowering; Edgeworthia chrysantha 'Akebono' or 'Red Dragon', with red-orange blooming, a more supple port, and less graphic than 'Nanjing Gold' or the species type. It is not found in Bulgaria. 5 Classification Expand this section. It is such a beautiful plant. Carolyn. Great info, Liane. It was planted in late winter, and now, June 20th is showing some yellow leaves on the lower branches. Carolyn. Im so glad that you are selling them in PA. Ive transported quite a number of these to my relatives there in the last ten years, and now have an excuse not to! Yet ww had no rain 4 months till the end of September. They all demand highly organic, fast-draining soil. 1 Names and Identifiers. NC State Extension no garantiza la exactitud del texto traducido. Carolyn, I am about 50 miles south of ATlanta and have grown two edgeworthia for about five years. Id probably just move it when I couldnt stand it anymore! No, I dont. I really appreciate everyone taking time to leave comments. Carolyn. Is there a particular variety you recommend? Only plants will be removed from the collection. The much sought after Edgeworthia Red Dragon is a winter flowering deciduous Chinese shrub with cinnamon coloured young bark and dense nodding terminal clusters of fragrant orange to red flowers which open in late winter. Ive had them for about 8 years and hardly do anything to maintain them, just pinestraw mulch seems to keep them happy. I bought 2 at the Scott sale last year, one of the species and one Red Dragon. How quickly does it grow? This was the day I fell in love with Edgeworthia chrysantha . Send Explanation. Edgeworthia is one of the stars of the winter garden - or should we say it's one of the suns? Photo: Andy Pulte. flowering Akebono cultivar which I planted here in my new home, a little farther east on Cape Cod. The lesser goldfinch has a larger range and is more common. Nakai belongs to Thymelaeaceae family, its alabastrum is used as the traditional Chinese medicine 'Buddleja Officinalis Maxim'. It doesnt seem to care about sun or shade, although full sun leads to droopy leaves in summer. How about fertilizers? Edgeworthia chrysantha 'Nanjing Gold' Gold Flowered Paper Bush Edgeworthia papyrifera. I am in SE Michigan also, so it would be interesting to compare notes. In Japan, the paper is used to make banknotes. Because the shape is so beautiful and the shrubit is over 7 feet tall and wide nowI can hardly tell where I pruned the branch. In season, the shrub seems fine, but if relocation will help, well find a better spot for it. Although hardy to -5C (23F), this deciduous, spreading shrub benefits from a sheltered position prevent frost damage to the flowers. I have never done it but I dont see why pruning would be a problem. Although it is fairly flexible as to its growing conditions, edgeworthia has the best form and is healthiest in full to part sun. To all reports, it is less hardy and less floriferous. I thought they would be. 3793. Now I wish I had ordered a paper bush! Please use your imagination to envision how gorgeous this shrub must be covered with hundreds of the silky silver buds shown in the preceding photo. Les, Our edgeworhtias went limp quite a few times during the summer, but the flowers look fine now. Hank, I guess the edgeworthias were on a schedule of their own this year. Thank you!!! As edgeworthias age, if you have a little patience, you can root your own by allowing a ground sprout to grow awhile and placing a brick on it to encourage root development. Two fragrant and vigorous climbing plants for a spectacular With its rich purple blooms, Clematis Etoile Violette' is a Use our interactive toolsto design your dream garden. This well-branched, well-formed shrub begins forming its silvery buds in late summer into fall, adding interest to your fall garden. There is an evergreen dogwood called something like Empress of China that might work. Edgeworthia is native to China and was named for Michael Edgeworth (1812 to 1881), a plant collector for the East India Company. My Edgeworthia is in a SE facing spot, with partial shade. No routine pruning is necessary. This large, sculptural shrub commanded attention in the center of a network of pathways. Carolyn, If you are following these comments, you will want to know that I have posted an additional article on edgeworthia called Edgeworthia Update. Commenters on my first post agree with Andrew's assessment. So, my question is should I rather plant it on the East side of the house with afternoon shade or on the south side under the semi shade from grape vines??? For immediate help or to order plants call 919-772-4794, 8-5 M-F (ET). My 1990 edition of Michael Dirr's Manual of Woody Landscape Plants contains no mention of it, and it was not covered in my 1994 Longwood course, Deciduous Flowering Shrubs II. I would just have to goggle it. However, the Chanticleer specimen in the sun is much lower and tighter while Charles Cressons shady specimen is taller and looser. Carolyns Shade Gardens is a retail nursery in Bryn Mawr, PA, U.S., zone 6b/7a. Insects, Diseases, and Other Plant Problems:No significant problems. Love these plant, not much care needed, tho do find the constant yellow leaf drop annoying. My photos of the whole plant do not do justice to how gorgeous it is, but as I reviewed the on-line literature, I realized that everyone has this problem. I like the slightly sprawling look this shrub has naturally. Carolyn. Wish I could see your garden. Carolyns suggestions for finding a microclimate and mulching are good ones, thanks Carolyn! My plant blooms prolifically and scents the whole side of the house. If it dies, plant another, they are fast growing. Vickie, Yes, edgeworthias can get quite large when they are happy. Carolyn. My best guess is too much wetness, although there was no obvious ground saturation, and it sits on a slight down-slope. I only prune right after the flowers have faded. 2022 Beckoning-cat.com. In The Heather Garden at Ft Tryon in Washington Heights NYC Mine are more exposed than other local plants so we will see. Cooperative Extension has offices in every county, Request and Invitation to Upcoming Classes, Edgeworthia Brightens the Winter Landscape, Bulbs, Corms and Tubers That Can Be Planted in Spring, Native Plants for Craven County Landscapes, 11. What zone are you? When you are ready to buy an edgeworthia for your garden, check out our edgeworthias for sale. Its very hardy and spreads from the root. I prefer edgeworthia shaped to a single stem, but have seen it grown multi-stemmed also. One thing is clear though: you wont regret adding edgeworthia to your garden. I also prune this after the blooms are finished because I would never sacrifice them. Carolyn, Carolyn, I remember seeing this shrub when we visited Chanticleer together last year, and somehow I could not admire it as much as you did. After leaves have fallen, bare branches host silver-hair covered flower buds that according to one observer, look like mouse toes. At least, I say I would. And the orange-flowered forms are about the same size and have the delicate branching of Edgeworthia papyrifera, but with beautiful reddish-orange flowers rather than pale yellow. Grown in the sun, the foliage is still acceptable, though not as lush green as a rhododendron grown in a shaded area. Prices range from $20 for species to $25 for 'Red Dragon . Cooperative Extension prohibits discrimination and harassment on the basis of race, color, national origin, age, sex (including pregnancy), disability, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, and veteran status. Sandra, Well I have now put myself out on a limb by ordering some of the strength of all this interest, but it really is a wonderful plant. Griffin, GA, Anna, thanks for adding to the information about edgeworthia. You can also purchase paper bushes from . The edgeworthia I bought from you in the fall is doing great, and we get to see it every time we walk from the street to the front door. Deleting this collection CANNOT be undone. It is not supposed to be as hardy. Joy, I have noticed that the lower leaves turn yellow and fall off, but I didnt know it was that regular. Another species of the paperbush is the Edgeworthia chrysantha 'Akebono,' also known as the red dragon. In full bloom, this plant produces a nice splash of fragrant, yellow flowers grouped at the ends of reddish-brown stems. This may be one for future planting when some of my trees and shrubs get up a bit. Carolyn. The small, yellow, strongly fragrant, pendant flowers hang in hemispherical clusters from the bare branch tips from February to April. I even did a radical pruning (you might say chopping) on a giant one that outgrew its space and then moved it to entirely different conditions (from part sun moist to bone dry shade) and darned if the thing isnt regrowing beautifully from the bottom up! Barbara, I remember the first time I saw the buds. Edgeworthia flowers exude a sweet fragrance similar to Daphne, further enhancing their sunny disposition. guildford school of acting auditions; gilroy google font alternative; cuisinart steamer insert; Blog Post Title February 26, 2018. Carolyn. Edgeworthia thrives in partial shade and appreciates well-enriched, moist soil.

Identify The Incorrectly Punctuated Sentence In The Group, Articles E